Our 5 Tests

United Utilities are reviewing their application to renaturalise Crummock. We set out five tests we want to see met by their new proposals.

1. History & Heritage

The future of Crummock must be based on its natural past. Since the ice age, this has been a natural reservoir surrounded by a remarkable landscape. To protect this and avoid scarring the landscape we want to see a scheme that:

  • Respects the historic lake levels and channels

  • Renaturalises the outlet

  • Does not impact the visual landscape

2. Wildlife & Biodiversity

Crummock has unusual low nutrient properties that that result in exceptional clear water and rare ecological balance. This makes it especially vulnerable to pollution and disturbance. Our priority is to protect and enhance nature:

  • Recognise the extraordinary wildlife supported by the Lake and its surroundings

  • Minimise the short term impact on biodiversity.

  • Provide high levels of mitigation for any planned works

3. Access & Accessibility

Lanthwaite woods, Brackenthwaite How and the shoreline of Crummock are iconic outdoor spaces, loved by West Cumbrians for their beauty and accessibility. Access to the lake should not be diminished, it should be enhanced. We say:

  • Protect rights of way that have existed for centuries

  • Maintain shoreline bridges

  • Identify opportunities to enhance accessibility

4. Construction

Any change needs to accept interference. Removal of concrete channels, wave walls and gantries will create a more natural landscape at the lake outlet. But such demolition impacts on the nature. It releases CO2, creates noise, air and water pollution. Lorton roads are not designed for heavy construction vehicles. Water pollution settles on spawning grounds wiping out fish populations. We say:

  • Look to bury structures in place rather than removing them

  • Minimise lake bed disturbance

  • Adopt lower impact methods to remove obsolete infrastructure over a longer period of time.

5. Community

The scheme needs integrity, vision and respects the Community on which it impacts.

Landowners, downstream farmers, residents threatened by flooding, local businesses, fishermen, swimmers, walkers, kayakers, divers, visitors are all part of this community.

Genuine consultation is essential.

We want to see the views of residents, Parish Councils, Consultee Groups properly considered. A scheme that is embraced by the nation, not forced on it.